November 18, 2025

Broken or Boring? Is Your Website Telling the Right Story?

A website can work perfectly and still describe a company that no longer exists. How to tell a technically outdated site from a strategically outdated one, and what to do first.

by
Sarah Dowlin

A marketing director once told me she received the website copy back from her agency and stayed up well past 10 p.m. rewriting it.

This is a true story from a veteran marketing director who later became a WorkLife Studios client. I've heard similar tales from operations leaders and founders at well-established firms.

They finally pulled the trigger on a new website. Committed to the investment. Yet somewhere along the way, they found themselves struggling to articulate what made their business distinctive.


Technically outdated vs. strategically outdated

When business leaders describe their website as outdated, they're typically describing one of two problems.

A technically outdated website has practical limitations. A strategically outdated website no longer reflects the company it represents.

Technically outdated Strategically outdated
The website is difficult to update. It describes services or capabilities from an earlier chapter.
The design looks dated compared to competitors. The messaging sounds like every other firm in the industry.
The mobile experience is cumbersome. Your team explains the business better than your homepage does.
The original developer is no longer available. Leadership, structure or strategic direction has changed.
Images are low-resolution or poorly formatted. The photography no longer reflects your people, culture or work.

In our work with clients, we've encountered both:

  • A commercial real estate developer whose seven-year-old website failed to showcase some of its most significant recent projects.
  • A law firm prompted to modernize its website when a new competitor entered the market.
  • A company consolidating three business units under one brand.
  • A consulting firm looking to expand its established in-person services into online education.

Often, it's a practical problem that gets the website project approved. But addressing the strategic problem is what makes the investment worthwhile.


When your reputation outgrows your website

For relationship-led businesses, a website is rarely the beginning of a relationship.

A prospective client hears about your firm through a trusted colleague. A business development manager makes an introduction. A potential employee meets someone from your team. A longtime client recommends you to a friend.

Eventually, many of those people visit your website.

What they find should reinforce what they've already heard.

Instead, they may encounter generic messaging, stock photography, an incomplete portfolio or a description of services that barely scratches the surface of what your team is capable of delivering.

‍The cost may never show up in your website analytics. But it's a missed opportunity to build upon the trust you've already established.

Consider how much your organization invests in developing its reputation: years of client service, professional development, business development, community involvement and relationship building.

Your website should be working in concert with those investments.
‍

Why a new website can still feel like someone else's

When a business decides it's time for a new website, the natural first step is often to hire a website designer or developer.

But what happens when the designer needs your content?

For many small and midsized firms, the responsibility falls to someone already managing a demanding role. Interviews need to be scheduled. Photography needs to be coordinated. Leadership needs to weigh in. Decisions need to be made about what the company wants to communicate.

What initially appeared to be a website project becomes an exercise in organizational alignment.

Even when copywriting is included in the scope, the quality of the finished content depends heavily on how well the writer understands the business.

A questionnaire can capture facts. A conversation can clarify objectives. But discovering what truly distinguishes an organization often requires spending time with its people, listening to different perspectives and observing how the business operates.

There's also a question of sequence.

If the website is designed before the story is understood, the content must conform to decisions that have already been made.

At WorkLife Studios, we think of website content and design much like a book. The manuscript informs how the pages are organized, how the cover is designed and how the story unfolds. Imagine handing an author a pre-designed book and asking them to fill in the pages.

In much the same way, web designers and developers can do their best work when they have a well-developed understanding of the business and a collection of written and visual content to build around.
‍

What does it mean to put the story first?

By story, we mean more than the words on a website. It's the understanding that informs what your website says, what it shows and how it's organized.

Putting the story first means exploring questions such as:

  • What has our business become since our last website was built?
  • What do our clients value about working with us?
  • Where are we going as an organization?
  • What distinguishes our approach from others in our industry?
  • What do prospective clients need to understand before they feel comfortable working with us?
  • What aspects of our culture and capabilities are better communicated through photography?

The answers influence everything from website navigation and service descriptions to photography and design.

Our own website is an example. Some pages, such as Approach, lend themselves to a more editorial experience. Others follow a traditional service-page structure. Our photography library influenced the visual direction throughout.

The website was built around the story of our business.
‍

Discovering the story your organization is already living

One of the most rewarding aspects of our work is discovering how much of an organization's story already exists within the experiences of its people.

At one small professional services firm, a partner used a memorable phrase during an interview to describe how she puts clients at ease.

It was a compelling sentiment. But it wasn't until I spent time with her during our photoshoot that I saw how naturally she embodied it.

That observation became the foundation for the narrative that shaped the website.

This is why our Story Discovery process brings together interviews, observation and photography. Each provides a different perspective on the same organization.

Rather than asking a leadership team to develop a compelling description of its culture, we create opportunities to discover that culture through the people who experience it.

It also gives leadership a stronger foundation for evaluating messaging. They're responding to a narrative informed by their organization's actual experiences, rather than an outside interpretation based on limited information.

In another project, a CEO remarked: “Wow, you got all of that from talking to us? We've been trying to express that for 50 years.”

The story was already there. It needed to be brought into focus.
‍

A test you can run this week

You don't need to commission a new website to determine whether your current one reflects the business you've become.

Start with these three exercises.

1. Listen to your team.

Ask several people across your organization to explain what your firm does, who you serve and why clients choose to work with you.

Compare their answers with one another and with your homepage.

Where are the consistencies? Where are the discrepancies? What are your people communicating particularly well that never makes it onto your website?

2. Look through your client's eyes.

Ask a longtime client to describe what they value most about working with your organization.

Then look at your website.

Is there evidence of what they've described? Can you find it in your messaging, photography, case studies or descriptions of your services?

3. Take inventory of what's changed.

Consider what's happened since your website was last developed.

  • New capabilities or services.
  • Changes in leadership.
  • Significant projects or accomplishments.
  • New markets or audiences.
  • Changes in company culture.
  • A shift in strategic direction.

Which of these developments are reflected on your website? Which are missing?

These exercises can help you determine whether your website needs a technical refresh, a renewed messaging strategy or a more comprehensive redesign.

Sometimes, the website itself isn't the problem at all.
‍

Before you invest in another website

A website is an opportunity to bring your organization's reputation, capabilities, people and ambitions into alignment with how you're represented online.

For some businesses, that means building something entirely new. For others, it means revisiting the story and photography within an otherwise functional website.

Either way, understanding the business should precede decisions about how to present it.

At WorkLife Studios, Story Discovery helps organizations uncover and articulate the story they're already living through interviews, observation and photography. For businesses preparing for a website redesign, that understanding becomes the strategic foundation for the work ahead.

Before investing in a better website, invest in a better understanding of the business it needs to represent.

about the author

Sarah Dowlin

Sarah Dowlin is a photographer by trade, an observer by nature, and the founder of WorkLife Studios. Drawing on nearly two decades of experience inside organizations, she helps relationship-led businesses uncover and communicate their stories. Through her work, writing, and speaking, she explores Connection Marketing and the practice of paying attention.

Throughline

For people who believe relationships are their best business strategy.

Throughline is where we think out loud about the space between story and connection; relationships and growth.

Get Throughline in Your Inbox...

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Sarah Dowlin at WorkLife Studios with clients
Give Notice Button

Built for relationships, not reach.

We help relationship-led businesses uncover the stories that shape their reputation.